p {text-indent: 12px;}
"That which was from the beginning, which we have heard, which we have seen with our eyes, which we have looked upon and touched with our hands, con
cerning the word of life -- the life was made manifest, and we saw it, and testify to it ...." I John 1:1-2 (RSV)

"After his resurrection the disciples saw the living Christ, whom they knew to have died, with the eyes of faith (oculata fide)." Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologica, III, 55, 2 ad 1, as quoted in D. M. Stanley, Jesus in Gethsemane (New York, Paulist Press 1980).

Friday, February 26, 2016

Richard Hays - Conversion of the Imagination

Here is a portion of Colin James Smothers' blog post review of  Richard B. Hays' book,  The Conversion of the Imagination: Paul as Interpreter of Israel’s Scripture (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans, 2005), describing St. Paul's method,  which has been helpful to my study of First Corinthians: 

In Chapter 1, Hays turns to the book of 1 Corinthians to examine the question of the eschatological identity of the church of Corinth in Paul’s correspondence. He begins by looking at the direct quotation of Isaiah 45:14 in 1 Corinthians 14:25. Via the concept of metalepsis, Hays analyzes the context of Isaiah 45, which is alluded to in Zechariah 8:20-23 and Daniel 2:46-47, to point out that in their original contexts these passages are about the Gentile outsider being brought to worship Israel’s God after having recognized God’s presence with Israel (3). Hays argues that Paul has intentionally placed the predominantly Gentile church into the theological shoes of OT Israel by identifying the church not simply with OT Israel but as OT Israel. Hays calls this Pauline reading of these texts “apocalyptic,” since it makes use of an “eschatological hermeneutic” that has been shaped by the revealed event of the cross (4). According to Hays, this was “Paul’s missionary strategy in his confrontation with pagan culture … [to] draw[] upon eschatologically interpreted Scripture texts to clarify the identify of the church and to remake the minds of his congregations” (5). Hays sees this “hermeneutical move” deployed by Paul elsewhere—this time typologically—in 1 Corinthians 10:1-22. Here Hays argues that Paul describes the Corinthian church in terms reminiscent of the wilderness generation, which again identifies the church as occupying the theological space of OT Israel. Hays argues for the same church-Israel re-identification in 1 Corinthians 1:18-31 and 1 Corinthians 5:1-13, and from all of theses passages taken together Hays makes the case that Paul intentionally connected the NT church with OT Israel in order to effect a “conversion of the imagination” in NT believers, an imagination that allows the NT church to read Israel’s history as their history, and even to read themselves into Israel’s history.




Wednesday, February 24, 2016

James Dunn

I like this from James Dunn:
The Spirit opened up a whole new vista for the first Christians, and they were brave and bold enough to follow where the Spirit showed the way. If we are to fully appreciate Paul the apostle, Paul the theologian, Paul the church founder, we must take full account of this vital aspect of his gospel. Having been converted by the Christ to recognise that God’s saving righteousness reached out to embrace Gentile as well as Jew, Paul was also quick to recognise that God’s Spirit was breaking away from the old patterns established by scripture and sanctified by tradition. This is why Christians need to rediscover Paul and to let him provide a fresh challenge to our own traditions where they no longer express the life of the Spirit, and to restore to us a fresh vision of how the initiative of the Spirit may once again be taking us in unexpected directions.
Jesus, Paul, and the Gospels, (William B. Eerdmans 2011) by James D.G. Dunn. 

Sunday, January 3, 2016

Richard Hays - First Corinthians

I’m enjoying Richard B. Hays’ fast-paced commentary on First Corinthians.  The text of Paul's letter offers excellent support for Hays’ comments on the “conversion of the imagination,” as this passage illustrates:

            But, as it is written,
“What no eye has seen, nor ear heard,
nor the human heart conceived,
what God has prepared for those who love him”—

1 Cor 2:9  (NRSV).  In First Corinthians Paul challenges the believers to see with the "eyes of faith" realities which appear foolish to the people of that day.   Hays states, for example, “The scandal of this message is difficult for Christians of a later era to imagine. To proclaim a crucified Messiah is to talk nonsense.”   Here from Hays’ comments to chapters 1 and 2 are beautiful remarks on what First Corinthians opens with and promises to deliver:

“By the end of the first nine verses [of ch. 1], Paul has sketched a sweeping picture of the Corinthian church’s calling: They have been called by God to participate in a movement, along with others all around the known world, to extend the destiny of Israel by living as a covenant people set apart for the service of God. God has lavished upon them spiritual gifts that enable their mission of bearing witness to the grace of Jesus Christ, and God supports and strengthens the community during the present age, while they await God’s final judgment of the world.”
            …
“Consequently, to enter the symbolic world of the gospel is to undergo a conversion of the imagination, to see all values transformed by the foolish and weak death of Jesus on the cross.”

Hays, Richard B., First Corinthians: Interpretation: A Bible Commentary for Teaching and Preaching (Westminster John Knox Press 2011). 
Richard B. Hays  Credit:   Duke Divinity School

Saturday, November 14, 2015

Paris November 13 and George Eldon Ladd's The Gospel of the Kingdom

After what just happened in Paris, today is a good day to reflect on the words of Jesus in the Olivet Discourse (Mark 13, Matt 24 and Luke 21).   George Eldon Ladd wrote:

The Kingdom is assaulting the kingdom of Satan. This conflict will last to the end of The Age. Final victory will be achieved only by the return of Christ. There is no room for an unqualified optimism. Our Lord’s Olivet Discourse indicates that until the very end, evil will characterize This Age. False prophets and false messiahs will arise and lead many astray. Iniquity, evil, are so to abound that the love of many will grow cold. God’s people will be called upon to endure hardness. “In the world you have tribulation” (John 16: 33). “Through many tribulations we must enter the kingdom of God” (Acts 14: 22). We must always be ready to endure the tribulation as well as the kingdom and patience which are in Jesus (Rev. 1: 9). In fact, our Lord himself said, “He who endures to the end will be saved” (Matt. 24: 13). He who endures tribulation and persecution to the uttermost, even to the laying down of his life, will not perish but will find salvation. “Some of you they will put to death.... But not a hair of your head will perish” (Luke 21: 16, 18). The Church must always in its essential character be a martyr church. As we carry the Gospel into all the world, we are not to expect unqualified success. We are to be prepared for opposition, resistance, even persecution and martyrdom. This Age remains evil, hostile to the Gospel of the Kingdom.
…
The visible Church, we are told, is to be completely leavened by evil doctrine. Apostasy is so to pervade the Church that only a small remnant will be found faithful to God’s Word. The closing days of This Age will be the Laodicean period when the entire professing Church will be nauseatingly indifferent to eternal issues. In such a portrayal of the last days, God’s people can expect only defeat and frustration. Evil is to reign. The Church age will end with an unparalleled victory of evil. Sometimes so much stress is laid upon the evil character of the last days that we receive the impression (unintended, to be sure) that the faster the world deteriorates the better, for the sooner the Lord will come. It cannot be denied that the Scriptures emphasize the evil character of the last days. In fact, we have already made this emphasis. The evil which characterizes This Age will find a fearful intensification at the very end in its opposition to and hatred of the Kingdom of God.
George Eldon Ladd - Credit babelio.com

This does not mean, however, that we are to lapse into pessimism and abandon This Age and the world to evil and Satan. The fact is, the Gospel of the Kingdom is to be proclaimed throughout the world. The Kingdom of God has invaded This present evil Age. The powers of The Age to Come have attacked This Age. The last days will indeed be evil days; but “in these last days (God) has spoken to us by a Son” (Heb. 1: 2). God has given us a Gospel of salvation for the last days, a Gospel embodied in One who is Son of God. Furthermore, “in the last days it shall be,” God declares, “that I will pour out my Spirit upon all flesh” (Acts 2: 17). God has spoken for the last days; God has poured out His Spirit in the last day to give power to proclaim the divine Word. The last days will be evil, but not unrelieved evil. God has given us a Gospel for the last days, and He has given a power to take that Gospel into all the world for a testimony unto all the nations: then shall the end come.

Ladd, George Eldon. The Gospel of the Kingdom: Scriptural Studies in the Kingdom of God  (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1959) (from chapter 9, titled,  “When Will the Kingdom Come?”).


Saturday, August 29, 2015

Newbigin - The Christian Congregation


This is a Bible blog.  But compare the importance of activities such as Bible study, or blogging, with the importance of the Christian congregation.  Lesslie Newbigin, in  The Gospel in a Pluralist Society (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans, 1989), at page 227 writes: 
"I have come to feel that the primary reality of which we have to take account in seeking for a Christian impact on public life is the Christian congregation. How is it possible that the gospel should be credible, that people should come to believe that the power which has the last word in human affairs is represented by a man hanging on a cross?
I am suggesting that the only answer, the only hermeneutic of the gospel, is a congregation of men and women who believe it and live by it. I am, of course, not denying the importance of the many activities by which we seek to challenge public life with the gospel– evangelistic campaigns, distribution of Bibles and Christian literature, conferences, and even books such as this one.
But I am saying that these are all secondary, and that they have power to accomplish their purpose only as they are rooted in and lead back to a believing community.”

Monday, July 13, 2015

Feed My Lambs - Agnes Sanford

Peter loved Jesus and told him so, as we read in John 21.  The response of Jesus was, "Feed my lambs."  Jn. 21:17.   This order that Christian leaders should help people, should feed the lambs, inspired Agnes Sanford to to do her work.    I'm reading Sanford's books again, which brought to mind this post from 2012:

Healing of Memories
          In a previous post dated July 10,2012, I thought of  Peter who had to live with memories of his denials of Jesus.  Jesus intervened  after his resurrection by assuring and challenging Peter as described in John chapter 21.   This John chapter 21 encounter raises a good issue:  Do the healing effects of new life in Christ include healing of bad memories?  

           The place to start here  is with new creation theology.   In 2 Cor 5:17, St. Paul writes, "So whoever is in Christ is a new creation: the old things have passed away; behold, new things have come" (NAB).  We see this in the words and deeds of Jesus as well, in John chapter 3,  where Jesus tells Nicodemus that he needs a new birth.  When a person converts to Jesus, all is new.  The past does not matter.  But how deeply into the mind  does the healing light of Christ penetrate?
           One fascinating response to this question comes from the famous spiritual healer, Agnes Sanford (1897-1982).   I remember reading her autobiography, Sealed Orders (Bridge-Logos 1972)  in 1976 when I was 20 years old.   At that time I knew a few people who thought they had the gift of healing and who made prayers for  "inner healing" of bad memories part of their ministry.  That was not for me.  But I was enthralled with Sealed Orders.  It is the great story of a hopeful Christian who writes with the descriptive skills of a novelist.
          Sanford was raised in China as  the child of a missionary.  After she married an Episcopalian pastor she lived in New England.      At 20 years old, I did not have much theological sophistication, or ability to scrutinize the pros and cons of the spiritual healing ideas of Agnes Sanford.   Many  have been critical. See  http://hbcdelivers.org/?p=732   (concluding that Sanford's  inner healing is a dangerous combination of psychology and new-age spirituality). But at that time I missed the new-age issue.   For me reading Sealed Orders  was an experience of reading simple and beautifully stated  eyewitness testimony, describing people who saw their emotional lives turned around for the better after Sanford's  prayers to Jesus for this kind of spiritual healing. 
          My memories of reading  Sealed Orders  35 years ago are  of a person frustrated with Christians who lived as though Jesus never rose from the dead.  She believed that Jesus is alive, and that he offers his healing touch today just as he did during his public ministry on earth - a touch  that included this "inner healing" of bad memories.  If Agnes Sanford had lived in the days of Acts chapter 6 I bet that  she would have gone over with  the Hellenists who with their  free spirits and visioning of the risen Jesus (Stephen)  felt constrained and limited by the Jerusalem church.   See Martin Hengel,  Between Jesus and Paul: Studies in the Earliest History of Christianity,  Trans. John Bowden.  London: SCM, 1983 [German essays 1975-83].
          Yes, the church rightly puts a check on those who would claim the ability to solve complicated mental health issues with prayer.   But if Jesus,  the Lord of heaven and earth,  can be surprising in the ways that he heals and changes people,  then even if I may not go along with all of their ideas I like to keep an open mind and  listen to the voice of healers like Agnes Sanford. 
         Here is Agnes Sanford  thinking back to her  days in China  when she first considered the possibility that healing was part of the Christian life.  She recalls wondering if as a young girl  she with prayer could have helped a women who  suffered from severe depression:  

It would have been easy to heal this lovely lady even as I long afterword was healed.  If only some one of God's ministers had known that he himself was a channel for God's power and had laid his hands on her and prayed for the love of Jesus to come into her and lift her out of darkness into his light!   All my life I have grieved that no one knew how to pray for her.   But for the first time now, as I write this down, I wonder:  could I myself have prayed for her and channeled God's power into her?   I knew nothing about healing.    …
Could I have prayed for her daily in silence and in secret as I prayed for the young man?  Was that what God wanted me to do? 

Perhaps the reader is thinking, “Well, of course!”  But in those days it was not, “Of course.” We were fundamentalists. That meant that we believed implicitly in every word in the Bible, yet we did not believe in healing through prayer. We were supposed to obey Jesus in every word that He said. Yet, when He said, “The works that I do shall ye do also,” we  didn’t obey Him, and indeed considered it heresy that any one should try to do His works.”  


Sealed Orders, p. 49.

         Today if you use the word "channel" in Christian circles, there will be raised eyebrows, and I suppose there should be.  But in 1972 Agnes Sanford thought of herself as a channel not as a new-ager but as a matter of  simple obedience to Jesus.   When St. Francis said, "Make me a channel of your peace," nobody questioned his orthodoxy. 
         This subject is not a matter for  intellectual curiosity or theological speculation.  We are talking about people's lives here.  After writing about Agnes Sanford I got home to find the July 23, 2012  issue of the TIME magazine on the kitchen counter, and I saw on the  cover  “One a Day - Every day one U.S. soldier commits suicide."   In the TIME story by journalists Mark Thompson and Nancy Gibbs, they write:  “The U.S. military seldom meets an enemy it cannot target, cannot crush, cannot put a fence around or drive a tank across. But it has not been able to defeat or contain the epidemic of suicides among its troops.”     Agnes Sanford says about the Chinese woman, “I have grieved that no one knew  how to pray for her.”  And now with these children of our friends and neighbors who have served our country,  do we still not know how to pray and reach out with a healing touch?

A version of this blog post was originally on this blog site  July 13, 2012.

Monday, June 22, 2015

Word of God and People of God - Rabbi Sacks

What we call the OT has inspired many, even no-nonsense "unspiritual"  intellectuals like Hobbes:

However, if we look at the “birth of the modern” – at figures like Milton, Hobbes and Locke in England, and the founding fathers of America – the book with which they were in dialogue was not Plato or Aristotle but the Hebrew Bible. Hobbes quotes it 657 times in The Leviathan alone.
....
This too is the meaning of Isaiah’s remarkable statement: “You are My witnesses,” declares the Lord, “that I am God” (Isaiah 43:12). In its collective fate and destiny, Israel will constitute the most compelling evidence of divine involvement in human history. It will reach heights of achievement, and sometimes depths of degradation, that have no counterpart in the fate of other nations. As Tolstoy once wrote, “The Jew is the emblem of eternity.”

Jonathan Sacks,  Covenant and Conversation   Exodus: The Book of Redemption (Maggid Books 2010). Although I am not Jewish, I agree with Rabbi Sacks that the  Hebrew Bible and the history of the Jewish people are compelling evidence of God's involvement in human history.